Interest earned in a savings account or taxable brokerage is subject to income or capital gains tax, while paying off debt gives you a guaranteed, tax-free return equal to your debt APR.
Debt vs Savings Calculator
Compare whether paying down debt or investing extra cash delivers the higher net worth after interest and taxes.
Currency
Time Horizon
Debt Obligations18.5% APR
$
Available Extra Cash To Allocate
$
$
Savings & Investment Return4.5% APY
Paying Debt Wins By
$4,346.87
Advantage over 3 years after 20% yield tax
Pay Debt Net Position$3,297.29
Save & Invest Net Position-$1,049.58
After-Tax Savings Return3.60%
Break-Even Pre-Tax APY23.13%
3-year strategy comparison
Net position equals ending savings minus remaining debt at the end of year 3.
| Strategy | Interest Paid | After-Tax Yield | Ending Debt | Ending Savings | Net Position |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pay Down Debt First | -$2,138.01 | +$35.31 | $0.00 | $3,297.29 | $3,297.29 |
| Save & Invest | -$7,345.80 | +$896.22 | $17,345.80 | $16,296.22 | -$1,049.58 |
| 50 / 50 Split | -$4,648.82 | +$448.11 | $6,948.82 | $8,148.11 | $1,199.29 |
Other Personal Tools
Explore related calculators or view all YoFi tools.